Skip to content
Motor control

DOL, soft starter or VSD: choosing a motor starting arrangement

Compare DOL, soft starters and VSDs by motor duty, starting conditions, PLC data, communications and MCC layout, with practical CWS examples.

Chris Wilson, Clive Wilson SwitchboardsPublished 5 min read
Choose the starting arrangement from the driven load, the supply and the information the control system needs. DOL connects the motor directly to the supply, a soft starter controls starting and stopping, and a VSD controls frequency and voltage during operation. Communications and diagnostics matter on fixed-speed duties as well as variable-speed ones.

Follow the operating requirement

This is an initial selection route, not a substitute for motor and application data. Other arrangements, including star-delta starting, can be relevant but need their own assessment. A motor’s kW rating alone does not settle the choice.

Select the product from the actual torque and starting duty. Some soft starters offer low-speed or pump functions, but their permitted duty differs from continuous VSD operation. Check the selected manufacturer instructions.

What changes when the starting method changes?

Main selection considerations
RequirementDOLSoft starterVSD
Running speedNormally determined by supply frequency and motor/load characteristics.Normally fixed-speed operation after starting.Adjustable within the approved motor and process operating range.
Starting behaviourDirect starting duty must be acceptable.Starting current and torque profile depend on motor, load and selected settings.Acceleration and torque capability depend on the selected drive and control method.
Equipment scopeSwitching, overload and short-circuit protection with the required controls.Starter, protection and any internal or external bypass arrangement.Drive, protection, controls and any necessary EMC, output or harmonic measures.
Assembly planningSpace, connections and thermal duty still matter.Account for start duty, bypass operation and component losses.Account for continuous losses, clearances, cable routing and cooling.
Selection evidenceManufacturer coordination and motor duty.Application duty and coordinated equipment combination.Drive duty, overload capability, motor and installation instructions.
PLC data and communicationsContacts, a communicating starter or motor-management equipment, according to the selected design.Product-dependent current, status and diagnostic data; confirm protocol and available values.Product-dependent current, fault, energy and process data; confirm protocol, options and register map.

A bypass arrangement also needs to be defined carefully. A soft starter’s bypass is not the same as an engineered mains bypass around a VSD. If a VSD bypass is proposed, specify its interlocks, protection, operating sequence and whether the process can safely run at mains-frequency speed.

Four example duties

A fixed-speed transfer pump

The required flow is stable, but the pipework is sensitive to the starting and stopping transition. A soft starter is a candidate, subject to the pump, motor and hydraulic assessment. The electrical ramp alone does not prove acceptable pressure transients.

A ventilation fan with changing demand

The operating requirement includes speed control. A VSD is a candidate. Define the actual speed range, feedback, minimum operating conditions and motor cooling requirements rather than selecting only by nameplate kW.

A loaded process conveyor

Starting torque and acceleration are central. A soft starter’s reduced-voltage start may not provide the needed acceleration for every loaded condition. Assess the torque-speed duty and the selected drive or starter against the application.

A fixed-speed pump on a networked plant

The PLC needs current, trip details and energy data. Compare the data and operating functions available from a communicating starter and a VSD. Choose the arrangement that meets the plant requirements, including heat, EMC and lifecycle cost.

Bring the supply and protection into the decision

Provide the supply voltage, available fault information and any network or site constraints on starting. Consider the effect on other equipment as well as the motor being started. Where a drive is proposed, establish whether harmonic or EMC assessment is required and who is responsible for it.

Select the breaker, contactor or starter and overload from the manufacturer’s coordination data for the actual voltage and duty. Specify Type 1 or Type 2 coordination where required, and check the complete combination rather than one device’s breaking capacity.

Use the manufacturer’s data for the actual voltage, product combination and operating duty. Record any required coordination type or selectivity objective in the specification so it can be checked rather than assumed.

The information that prevents a wrong selection

  • Motor voltage, rated current, power and nameplate data.
  • Driven equipment, starting load and whether a restart can occur under load.
  • Acceleration and stopping requirements, starts per hour and duty cycle.
  • Required running-speed range and any process limitations.
  • Ambient conditions, altitude where relevant and equipment location.
  • Motor-cable details, feedback, communications and protective sensors.
  • Local controls, reset authority and the intended response after a trip or supply loss.

Do not copy the settings from a similar motor without checking the duty. Two motors with the same nameplate can drive very different mechanical loads. Energy-saving claims also need a duty profile and system assessment; adding a VSD does not guarantee a particular percentage reduction.

Finish the decision at assembly level

Once the starting method is selected, the MCC still needs a supported construction, adequate cable space, the required separation and a verified thermal arrangement. A drive selected to its own product standard must also be appropriately incorporated into the assembly.

CWS builds DOL and soft-starter feeders in Simotrol MCCs and plans VSDs in separate ventilated cubicles where the drive size, heat and project arrangement call for them. Use the motor-schedule checklist to send the duty, PLC data and interfaces together.

Finished industrial switchboard manufactured by Clive Wilson Switchboards
Finished industrial switchboard manufactured by Clive Wilson Switchboards.

References and further reading

Start with the motor duty.

Send the motor schedule, operating sequence and supply constraints so the feeder arrangement can be defined.

Plan an MCC with CWS
IP Geolocation by DB-IP · CC BY 4.0